Following Donald Trump’s re-election, Pastor Ben Boswell of Myers Park Baptist Church in Charlotte delivered a sermon comparing the political moment to the rise of Hitler. He warned that marginalized communities would suffer and called on congregants to bear witness. While his words earned a standing ovation, weeks later, the church’s board of deacons voted 17-3 to ask him to step down.
Declining Attendance and Financial Struggles
Church leaders cited declining attendance and financial struggles as the primary reasons for Boswell’s removal. Weekly attendance had dropped from 350 in 2016 to 150 in 2023. Contributions also declined, shrinking the church’s budget by nearly 25% since 2020. Some members, like Deacon Robert Dulin, believed Boswell’s outspoken approach alienated congregants, saying, “We have got to put more butts in the seats.”
Divided Congregation Over Social Justice Messaging
Many congregants appreciated Boswell’s commitment to racial and social justice, but others felt overwhelmed. Some white members said they grew tired of weekly sermons focusing on systemic racism, immigration, and LGBTQ+ rights. “I was ready for less guilt-trip and more love,” said longtime member Carol Pearsall. Others, like Bruce Griffin, a Black congregant, felt betrayed by the church’s decision, arguing that the removal signaled a retreat from inclusivity.
A Generational and Philosophical Divide
The decision highlighted a generational split within the church. Younger, more progressive members supported Boswell’s activism, while older members favored a more measured approach. Nicholas Rhyne, a 30-year-old congregant, said, “There’s a group of us who are younger and more passionate … who are fed up with just being told to wait.” Meanwhile, some church leaders argued that Boswell prioritized activism over pastoral care, leaving members struggling with personal crises feeling unsupported.
The Future of Myers Park Baptist Church
Church leaders insist that social justice remains a priority despite Boswell’s departure. However, critics fear the move signals a shift away from the church’s progressive stance. Three deacons resigned in protest. Boswell remains unapologetic, saying, “Our job right now is not to back away but to double down.” Whether Myers Park Baptist can balance social justice advocacy with growing its congregation remains an open question.
Source:
Pastor pushed out after parishioners complain about focus on racial justice
About Post Author
