First Christian Reformed Church (First Church), the oldest Christian Reformed Church (CRC) in Grand Rapids, Michigan, is preparing to leave the denomination over its stance on LGBTQ inclusion. The congregation, one of the original four that formed the CRC in 1857, voted overwhelmingly (143–16) to disaffiliate. Leaders of First Church stated that their faithfulness requires them to separate from a denomination that once nurtured them but has now taken a firm stance against LGBTQ inclusion.
CRC’s Stance on LGBTQ Inclusion Sparks Division
The CRC formally codified its opposition to same-sex relationships in 2022, and in 2024, it mandated that all congregations align with this doctrine or separate. This has led to a growing rift, with at least 23 churches formally announcing their intent to disaffiliate. First Church initially sought a compromise by welcoming all members to full participation without explicitly affirming same-sex relationships. However, the CRC deemed this position unacceptable, requiring full doctrinal alignment from its congregations.
A Painful Decision for First Church and CRC Members
First Church leaders emphasized that their decision was not made lightly. Since 2018, the congregation engaged in discussions about sexuality, attempting to balance inclusivity with their Reformed faith. While some members left in response to the church’s stance, the greater conflict arose when the denomination refused to accept First Church’s approach. CRC leaders maintain that the denomination is simply upholding its long-standing beliefs on sexual morality. However, members on both sides of the split express grief over the division, with many describing it as a painful separation of deeply connected communities.
Uncertain Future for First Church
Following the final vote on March 2, First Church will determine its next steps. Options include becoming independent or joining another denomination, such as the Presbyterian Church (USA), the United Church of Christ, or even the Reformed Church in America—the very denomination it left in 1857 to establish the CRC. Despite the sorrow surrounding the departure, First Church plans a “Night of Remembering” event to honor its 168-year history within the CRC.
Source:
Founding Congregation to Exit Christian Reformed Church
Photo by Mitchell Leach on Unsplash
About Post Author
